RocketShip Games

Matt and I got in a quick round of Battlefleet Gothic the other night, playing out a bare bones Cruiser Clash scenario to re-acquaint on some of the rules.

Matt fielded, I believe, a Styx class cruiser, and I fielded a Lunar class.  My cruiser mostly got pummeled, and limped out of the game with just two hits remaining.  The effort was mostly salvaged, however, but a late game direct torpedo longshot.  Capitalizing on the Chaos cruiser moving too quickly, my crippled ship poured everything into turning about and laying on a salvo in the opening.  Between the damage and the special orders to heave to, my crew only got off two torpedoes in the shot.  Miraculously though, both torpedoes made it through the Chaos defenses and did enough damage to also cripple the Chaos heathens, saving my captain’s reknown.

The big take away from the game was that Imperial cruisers, with their side-only batteries and lances, are a lot less flexible than Chaos cruisers, which can generally target the front and side arcs.  They’re going to need multiple ships operating in concert to really counter that significant advantage, which will be difficult in the small-fleet campaign we’re hoping to begin shortly.

I just posted the 4th mission scenario for our Combat Patrol tournament.  As always, I’m not completely sure on how this one will work out, but I’m pretty happy with it so I thought I’d talk about it a little.

Structure

I think one neat aspect of the tournament is that it is indeed a tournament, but it also has a fairly strong campaign element, in a loose, fixed narrative sort of way.  It’s structured somewhat like Space Hulk, where players aren’t making real campaign choices and the outcomes only affect the story in limited ways, but there is indeed a distinct narrative in play.  From the start I’ve had a pretty clear conception of an abstract story I wanted the tournament to follow, and I hope that’s done a lot to tie the missions together, give them a more compelling background context, and make them more interesting via unique objectives and parameters.

How this works out is that each of the 5 rounds/6 scenarios is set within a generic campaign setting.  There are no names or anything concrete, but there is an unmistakeable notion of an Attacker invading a settlement, city, or colony in the quest to obtain something, and a Defender hard pressed to stop their onslaught.  A little flavor is injected into it by just a little bit of fluff in each writeup.  To highlight the generic, inclusive nature of the campaign though, this is always done from the Defender’s perspective, but with different factions involved.  So far we’ve had Guardsmen attacked by (Dark) Eldar, Orks escaping Tau, Marines swarmed by Tyranids, Imperials sieging Chaos Marines, and Dark Angels assaulting Imperials.  Each mission also has a brief summary of the current plot point, and the Attacker and Defender roles.  Most of the missions are asymmetric, with players swapping those two roles, further accentuating the narrative.  On the other end, Jason has also been writing up little story blurbs to go with the results on the web, providing little vignettes of the campaign from the perspective of his Blood Angels.

Real campaign choices have or will show up in two places: The 3rd round had two missions that had similar goals (Annihilation), but very different setups.  Which one we played was determined by how many games the Attackers and Defenders had respectively won in the first two rounds.  Similarly, some parameters of the final mission, and of course the result of the campaign as a whole, will be determined by how the abstract Attackers and Defenders are doing.

Background

It doesn’t affect anything, but we do actually have a campaign map we’re following along, providing some imagery and geometric anchoring to the story:

First the Attacker smashed the outer defenses (Mission 1: Listening Post).  Then the Defender tried to escape back to warn the others of the attack (Mission 2: Flight).  In our case, they were not successful and the invasion swarmed the inner defenses (Mission 3a: Blood Melee), while in other universes the Defender was warned and the Attacker forced to attempt opening a new breach (Mission 3b: Gunline).  Right now (Mission 4: Population), the Attacker has been largely halted, but a small raiding party has slipped into the settlement to pillage for some sort of artifact, knowledge, or person required for the next mission.

Mission 4: Population

In the current round, the Attacker is searching the area for a key required for the next mission and the ultimate conclusion of the campaign.  Whether the key is a code, possessed psyker, ancient relic, or whatever, it doesn’t really matter.  The Defender, of course, has to stop this.  Although the terrain isn’t really specified and doesn’t matter too much, the mission is envisioned to be a battle in a city, village, base, or other developed area, representing the two brawling it out throughout the settlement.  Both sides setup on opposite sides and then charge in to claim the objectives:

One note here is that the mission is symmetric.  The primary reason for this is that we’re running the last two tournament rounds in one evening and there won’t be enough time to run two games for each one. I do really like the asymmetric missions so I almost kept that going into the last round, but I also really want people to play more than one person that night.  Given that the club’s venue time is limited, I setup the mission so that it could work well with the match played as one game or two, the latter for us or other groups using it in the future.

Goals

The objectives are where Mission 4 starts to get interesting; at least, I think so.  Each objective represents property or people that the Attacker is searching through, and the Defender trying to keep away from them.  How this plays out in game terms is two-fold:

• Either player may shoot or assault the objective, treated as a very weak model, in order to destroy it.  This yields 1 Ransack Point.
• Either player may hold an objective for an entire turn to claim it. This yields 2 Protection Points.

This represents the Attacker hacking computers, rifling files, stealing artifacts, torturing people, whatever.  It also represents the Defender doing basically the same.
At the end of the game, victory is determined by the higher of a player’s Ransack or Protection Points.  In other words, if you have 2 Ransack Points and 4 Protection Points, you would score 4 points to be compared to the other player.

Morality

The beauty of this is that it both fits within the symmetric setup, giving both players the same rules, and enables them to conceptually fill different roles.  Further, it brings in an element of role playing.  Are you going to kill and destroy all the objectives, or are you going to try and protect or claim them?  This is accentuated a bit by one of the Bonus Points being for having Ransack or Protection Points, but not both.

I like this because it plays within the amorality of the 40k universe. Sure, the Attackers are probably bad guys.  But maybe not.  Maybe they’re just trying to stop something you’re too low down on the chain to know about.  Similarly, the Defenders may not be good guys, even if they might have the more traditionally sympathetic role.  There are a lot of factions in 40k that could easily decide it’s not worth risking people or material falling into enemy hands, and start preemptively slaughtering and destroying them.  With these mission goals, each player has that choice as well, and needs to fit that into their strategic picture.

On top of that, the Bonus Point highlights just a little the harsh, dualistic push of much of 40k—you might not be purely good, or purely bad, but it’ll cost you just a little to compromise.

Tournament Stuff

Another reason for the symmetric setup is that I wanted to keep things very balanced and straightforward in the last rounds to ensure fairness across the board.  It’s very easy for slight biases to creep in without notice, and while I think I’ve been vigilant about that in writing these missions, there have definitely been rounds that favored armies with lots of anti-vehicle for bunker busting, others that favored cheap transports for quick mobility, and so on.  The previous missions certainly didn’t go over the top, but I wanted to take extra care to keep in-game effects simple in the last rounds.  For example, I had originally been planning a set of stratagems for this mission in keeping with the City Fight theme, but in the end decided to keep it simpler.  We’ll see how it works out this Sunday!

Leading the invading thrust on the shadow world of Thruun, the Big Mek watched the figures moving amid the ruins, setting up sheltered fire lanes.  In his rising excitement he punted a Snotling off his Trukk, then pointed at another one, fixating it with his mad gaze before turning back to the ruins and exclaiming with a trill of anticipation, “Demz da Emperor’s boyz, and dat means a right propa’ fight for once!”

Jacob and I got down to our Round 3 match for the Combat Patrol tournament the other night.  Orks vs Space Marines in a showdown of brutality—the night was a killing fest, with fast, ferocious, and decisive fighting.  In each of the two games the losing player was whittled down to basically one model by Turn 3.

Apologies on the weird lighting and flash use in some of the photos; for some inexplicable reason the loft at Redcap’s was particularly dark this evening.

Mission

In Round 3, the Attackers have breached the Defender’s outer perimeter.  The Defender is playing out a desperate last stand to hold the line against the Attacker forces swarming all around.  Defender deployment is along a 6″ strip in the center of the table.  The Attacker can deploy along the opposing 6″ strips on either side of the table.  Victory conditions are a basic Annihilation setup, determined by Kill Points or elimination.  In addition, two objectives are placed, each worth a Bonus Point for holding.  Finally, each side has a Heroic Action their Patrol Leader can enact once per game by taking a Leadership Test.  For the Defender it grants Feel No Pain, and for the Attacker their choice of Furious Charge or Relentless.  The Defender also counts as Fearless in their deployment zone, since they have nowhere to retreat.

We set up a fairly open but pretty cool board.  The rectangular ruin piece made a nice, thematic terrain piece for the center line.  I particularly like that piece because it’s done up in much brighter colors than most GW gothic ruins, and has a lot of nice touches.  The barricades also helped give this central post a nice last-ditch feel.

Armies

I think Jacob brought roughly the following; I’m still not very good at differentiating and remembering Ork units:

• 3 Deff Koptas
• 3 squads of 10 boyz, 2 in Trukks
• 1 Big Mek with a squad of Nobs in a Trukk

As a side note, Jacob’s Big Mek was custom kitbashed to be his Patrol Leader specifically for the tournament, and he came out really nicely.

In my army, I dropped my usual Razorbacks to load up on Sternguard:

• 9 Sternguard with 1 Power Sword
• 1 Tactical Squad with Flamer and Missile Launcher
• 1 Tactical Squad with Plasma Gun, Missile Launcher, and Razorback
• 2 Landspeeders with 2x Heavy Flamers each

While I’m pretty happy with Razorbacks, I figured this mission would be a lot about standing and shooting, and a gunline of Sternguard seemed a reasonable way to do that.  I also dropped a lot of special amenities, like the Powerfist I usually roll on Tactical 1, in order to squeeze out more models.  I assumed I’d be assaulted and losing Marines super early, so I really wanted as many bodies on the table as possible and not a lot of flash.  I kept one Razorback to provide some mobility for taking one of the objectives.  I also kept the slightly expensive Plasmagun in order to Combat Squad it with a Missile Launcher and pop Trukks.  One note about that which I considered a lot in list planning is that the deployment zone setup meant that basically everybody would be in shooting range of everyone else from the start, and would be rapidly in Rapid Fire range.  The Landspeeders of course came loaded for crunching hordes in cover.

Game 1

Jacob won the rolloff and chose to deploy and go first.  He deployed somewhat cautiously, though I did not in the end successfully Seize Initiative.  I deployed all my infantry in a concentrated fire base around the central objective.  The vehicles I placed away behind the ruin in hopes of not losing the Landspeeders to Turn 1 Rokkit Launchas.

Now, I haven’t played against Orks a ton, and it was very clear from the get-go that I should have studied the Codex harder.  In particular, I forgot about the Deff Koptas’ Scout move, and watched in horror as Jacob promptly moved one into place to blast away at my Landspeeders in Turn 1.  Then, in Turn 1, I watched again in horror as one of them flew over my fairly closely packed firebase and dropped a Large Blast bomb satchel all over it…  Fortunately neither came to much, but they were definite “Oh snap!” moments for me.

My firebase was able to quickly take out two of the Deff Koptas though, which was a large mental relief, while the Landspeeders immediately dispatched the closest group of Boyz, flaming away at them in their crater foxhole.  The infantry then started taking apart Trukks, but the Orks were still able to advance very quickly on my position.  The firebase quickly found itself wrapped up in a single huge pileup assault entangling no less than all three of my infantry squads and two of Jacob’s.  This was an awesome mess to work out, with Marines and Boyz all over the place mixed and mingled together.

Fortunately, I lucked out huge in this scrum.  Taking advantage of their position in cover to strike first, all of the Marines landed excellent hits.  The Sternguard in particular devastated a whole squad of Boyz, easily shrugging off the paltry counter attack.  Taking heavy losses, both squads failed their morale and retreated, being immediately swept away to cement the quick victory.

That combat mostly decided the tide of the battle.  The firebase then picked off the remaining Kopta and Trukks while the Landspeeders torched a squad of Gretchins.  The Big Mek lurked through the ruins to enact a sneak attack on the Kingbreakers that claimed many a valiant battle brother, but the hobgoblin mechanic was quickly brought down by a thunderclap of combined fire.

Result: Kingbreakers’ Major Victory!  Only one Bonus Point though.  I should have tried playing out the turns to try and reach the other objective, but I didn’t think of it and it’s questionable whether I would have made it in time.  The writeup also should have noted that total annihilation implied taking all objectives as I intended, but I did not remember to include that.

Game 2

Jacob again won the rolloff and chose to deploy and go first.  As irony would have it of course, after the first game he decided to ignore Seize Initiative and deploy more aggressively only to have me promptly proceed to do so and steal the first turn.

I set up a firebase of almost all my units in the ruins cattycorner to the Defender ruins.  I was hoping it would be just far enough away that I’d be able to shoot away at the Orks without being assaulted too early.  I also put a squad on the opposing table edge.  There were two reasons for this:

• There wasn’t enough space to put them in cover in the firebase.
• I was hoping to press a choice for Jacob between going after the firebase with all his army and leaving this squad free to take his objective; or splitting his forces and not attacking the firebase as aggressively.

This time, however, the Landspeeders did not fare as well.  Although they took out some number of models, they were quickly eliminated by the Deff Koptas.  Their early loss was devastating to the ability of my army to put out enough firepower to stop the green tide.

After that, the pinwheeling fireballs of exploding Trukks managed to deliver Orks into my firebase and outpost all too early.  Things were particularly bad in the firebase, where a group of Boyz proceeded to begin steadily munching through the units there, eventually forming a pincer with another inbound mob and wiping out the Kingbreakers contingent.

In contrast, on the other edge of the world Sgt Goliant and his men put up a stalwart defense of their position.  All was for naught as they were eventually overrun, but their honor shall live on in perpetuity!  Sgt Goliant’s name in particular shall forever be whispered among the halls of the greatest warriors for his single-handed, multi-turn stand against the enemy, his faith in the Emperor repeatedly holding firm against no lesser foe than the combined might of a squad of Nobs, three Deff Koptas, and the Big Mek himself!

Result: Major Victory for Jacob, and both Bonus Point objectives held.  This one point difference puts him just two points behind me in the tournament, meaning I really need to recoup some points against my next two opponents.

Lessons

One is that I should have been thinking more clearly in the first game about working the end conditions so that I could have stalled to take the second objective.

I also need to pack a set of craters to replace exploded vehicles. That would have put Sgt Titus’ Combat Squad in the Razorback into difficult terrain when it was destroyed, and probably prevented them from being assaulted that turn, and thereby stalled the Ork advance into the firebase for a whole extra round.

I’m not really sure what to make of that second game.  My Landspeeders should have been better protected, but there really wasn’t enough terrain on the board to have them trying to stay in cover while other units tried to take out the Deff Koptas.  What I really should have done though is stuck to my usual Multi-Melta/Heavy Flamer loadout rather than double flamers, used the Speeders and their Multi-Meltas to take out the Deff Koptas in the early going, and then concentrated on flaming the Ork Troops.

It’s not super clear to me that it was a terrible decision to put the one squad on the other side of the table.  It is clear however that a large portion of my thinking was faulty—I’m so used to worrying about big strong templates coming down that I was really over worried about finding cover.  Against the weapons Jacob had, their armor was stronger than any cover and they could have just as effectively stood out in the open near the firebase.  However, it did split his units nicely and I’m not sure how much they would have helped the firebase given that Jacob’s whole concentration would have then just been directed there.

Orks seem to be a definite force at Combat Patrol.  They have so few selections outlawed by the rules that they’re basically choosing from almost their whole army list, including a couple reasonable Troop selections.  The small tables and tendency to drift into assault is also suited to them, both in terms of slugging it out in close combat, but also that many of their weapons are Range 18″ Assault 2, meaning they can start putting out a lot of shots early on, particularly in this scenario.

That said, I continue to be impressed at how Marines can hold up in combat, despite the general trend to denigrate Tactical Squads’ assault potential.  A good group of Marines, particularly more than one squad supporting each other, can do a pretty reasonable job.  Interestingly though, it feels almost non-linear.  A 5-man Combat Squad can easily get blown away in one shot, while a 10-man full squad can generally stick combat for a long time against even solid assault units.

One last and interesting point is that I believe I’ve been playing multiple assaults under too many constraints.  I had been reading the movement procedures as being based around enemy models in the unit you’re assaulting, but upon looking at it more it seems really to be based around any models.  That makes it significantly easier to engage and tie down multiple units.  Though, that said, we also saw the risks of that in Game 1 when Jacob’s units assumed huge aggregate penalties due to the combination of multiple assault results.

More photos from this match are in the Flickr gallery.

Recently, Pangloss and Equinox have been having a pretty good discussion about Combat Patrol in 5th Edition:

• Realms of Equinox: Tournament Tuesdays: Overhauling the Combat Patrol Rules
• Pangloss’ 40k: Thinking About Combat Patrol
• Pangloss’ 40k: More Thinking About Combat Patrol

In an earlier post I talked a bit about some of the reasons I like Combat Patrol, namely accessibility, faster games, and reduced rock-paper-scissors effects, which can be dramatic in low points games.  I’ve also talked a bit in the past about general issues in small 40k games.  I thought I’d add on to my earlier points with some more thoughts on revising the rules to better accommodate the current codexes and rules.

As a case in point for why revisions are necessary, consider the new Tyranid codex.  Due to the restrictions to 2 Wounds and 4+ Invulnerable saves, there are no Synapse Creatures permitted in Combat Patrol under the new book.  For those unaware, without coverage from Synapse, almost every Tyranid unit has to pass a Leadership check.  Otherwise it either storms toward the enemy or hides.  That severely hampers playing the new book in Combat Patrol, unless you field purely hordes of Genestealers, who are not subject to Synapse, but have no ranged weapons.  That also gets a little boring after a while.  This essentially eliminates a very popular army from playing, a substantial problem.

Points Limits

I agree that 750pts is pushing the upper bound for Combat Patrol; beyond that it’s too constricting and should generally be played as a standard game.  But I think a good set of rules could work well over ~250–750 pts, and create a game atmosphere that feels different from standard 40k but is similar enough to just sit down and go.  Like Equinox said, that’s an important goal.

A major determinant in what points levels work depends on what armies are used.  A friend and I regularly play 250pts.  That’s probably the lower bound without true skirmish rules, but we have fun though pushing models around at lunchtime. It works because he’s running Chaos Marines and I run Space Marines, and that’s just enough points to both have some choices and field some variety.  Other armies really struggle at even 400pts; Necrons are the classic example, Grey Knights are another.  Viable points levels depends a lot on who’s playing.

I think the set points clearly depends on what people what to get out of it, and there isn’t a need to be too strict about what is “Combat Patrol” and what’s not.  For example, one reason we’re running 750pts in our tournament is because it allows a good number of units, which in turn enables more varied mission scenarios.  At 400pts a lot of armies basically field only two units, so it’d be hard to have objectives and other special scenario goals.  Asymmetric scenarios, played with alternating roles, were also something we liked the sound of.  But, we also wanted people to be able to play after work.  The 750pt limit supports those competing goals, while also being a slightly longer match than 400pts.  We have, however, applied the Combat Patrol rules rather than just limiting the points, largely in order to prevent rock-paper-scissors list making issues.  Similarly, 400pts is very fast to play, very accessible, and a lot of fun in its own right.  There’s clearly a place for both.

HQs

A great number of HQ units definitely seem potentially unbalanced at these point levels, or not in the spirit of the missions if you care about that sort of thing.  I think you can keep out “crazy” HQs by keeping some sort of restriction against uniques, but let in the “regular” HQs by drifting the allowable wounds up to 3.  That enables IG Company Commanders, Tyranid Warriors, Space Marine Captains, etc., all of which are reasonable to me, but cuts out Abaddon, Marneus, etc., whom I think present problems.  More on “Uniques” later.

In any case though, I don’t think HQs should be required.  Too many are glass jaws to force them at this point level.  For example, a Space Marine Captain is actually a tough sell.  I wouldn’t say that they really bring in their 100+ pts on average; ditto Librarians—sometimes they come up huge, but a lot of times they don’t.  Chaplains also essentially force a unit to lose Combat Tactics, which is unfortunate.  All are solid selections in a full list with other units to synergize with and many other models on the table, but I wouldn’t want to be forced to take one with so few points available.  Conversely, I wouldn’t want them disallowed either.  For this week’s tournament mission, I would have strongly considered a Captain and Command Squad—the first time I’ve ever seriously thought of the latter—but the Captain is out due to the traditional 2 wounds restriction.

Heavy Supports

In my opinion, Armor Value restrictions keep out sufficient HS.  I wouldn’t ban HS completely and eliminate Devastators or Havocs, they don’t seem out of line for the feel of the game.

I also don’t see the traditional restriction against Ordnance as being necessary.  If someone wants to field a Basilisk, Predator, Whirlwind, or something, I’d be ok with it, and think it’s reasonably fluffy—a lone vehicle making its way to a new position with its escort or some such.  Especially on a smaller table, they’ll be prone to assault or concentrated attack, and the armor value on this units is not particularly higher than the transports; I don’t think they’d be dominating choices.

At 750pts I’d actually lift the armor restriction a bit, maybe to 34 total points rather than 33.  In that size army you can field enough options to have some reasonable anti-vehicle plan, and could work to take down more heavily armored vehicles.  I would probably not say this at 400pts though; the environment is just very different.  In particular, my experience has been that Dreadnoughts are devastating and frequently unstoppable at that point level.

Either way, even at 750pts I’d hesitate to let in a Land Raider, Monolith, or similar vehicle.  It’s true that they would be a huge points risk that might be taken out relatively easily—I’ve had Sternguard take out even an entire Baneblade by themselves in the first round of shooting, and Landspeeders can regularly do the same for Land Raiders.  But I think these are just too much of a rock-paper-scissors risk at these point levels for my taste.  Those also have accessibility issues for newer players trying to compete.

One idea that came up in our group is to have a total limit for the army.  Something like you can field any vehicles, but the combined armor across all of them must be less than 100 (or something).  That would let you use one or two big vehicles, or a couple smaller vehicles, or a mix.  It might be just as easy though to say “One vehicle with armor up to 34 (or 35, etc) and any number with armor up to 33.”

Elites and Fast Attack

Tight limits on FA and Elites are also problematic.  I think a squad of Sternguard and a couple Landspeeders is fairly fluffy for combat patrol.  Landspeeders, Rough Riders, and Sentinels all also provide for all-FA lists very much in keeping with the spirit of Combat Patrol.  Appropriate mission rules probably counter any problems here.  In our tournament, you could bring a ton of Elites, FA, etc., but many of the missions have objectives, so it behooves you to bring Troops, just like standard 40k.

General Unit Restrictions

Like Pangloss said, I also think Equinox’s proposed 200pt maximum per unit restriction is too tough, although the intent is good.  As noted, a squad of Marines is 170pts.  Add a Rhino or a Powerfist and a Plasmagun and they’re over that limit.  The problem with saying they can just take five man squads is then they don’t have access to heavy and special weapons.  Cheap weapons are one of the primary advantages for Space Marines compared to many races, and their main anti-horde and anti-vehicle counter abilities, so robbing them of that would really hinder them unfairly.

Lifting the permitted wounds to 3 is essentially required, if only to enable Tyranids a few viable Synapse Creatures.  It also permits the generic Space Marine Captains and Chapter Masters (and consequently Command Squads), IG Company Commanders, and many other units that don’t seem unreasonable.

Not discussed so far is if the traditional Combat Patrol restriction to no better than 3+/4+ saves should be relaxed.  I am torn on this.  One argument I see for relaxing it are Zoanthropes, an important Synapse Creature option for Tyranids.  However, if permitted wounds are bumped up—basically a requirement, I think—Tyranid players can cover Synapse via at least Warriors.  I also don’t see a reason to cut out Techmarines.  However, I have mixed feelings about Terminators.  They’re admittedly super hard to take down and could cleave through another army, but even at 750pts they would be a significant fraction of a list to invest in just a few models.  They also don’t generally score, so the mission scenarios will enforce some sort of natural balance.  Including them would also enable Dark Angels players to use their preferred codex and existing units.  One plausible option might be to allow 2+ armor saves, or 3+ invulnerables, but not both.  This would permit Zoanthropes, Captains in Artificier Armor, Honor Guards, Techmarines, etc., but not Terminators.

Similar to Equinox, I also don’t have issues with upgrade characters like Telion or Harker.  They just don’t seem that unbalancing; they’re useful, but they’re a bunch of points as well.  The key here is the wording, enabling these guys but keeping out crazy HQs.  Toward that end, I think the wording should be “No Unique Independent Characters, Unique Monstrous Creatures, or Special Characters.”  The rationale behind this specific wording is based on:

• Space Marines: Telion does not technically say Unique (he has a special rule limiting him to 1 squad), but Chronus does; neither are Independent Characters.  The fancy HQ characters are of course all Unique Independent Characters.
• Chaos Marines: All named characters are Unique Independent Characters.
• Orks: Snikrot and Zagstruk are not Independent Character, nor technically Unique, and hence would be allowed.  The few named HQs are Unique Independent Characters.
• Tau: Aun’va, Farsight, and Shadowsun use the old terminology and are listed as Special Characters, not as Uniques.
• IG: Yarrick is a Unique Independent Character; all the company commander characters and other upgrades are Unique, but not Independent Characters.  Marbo is also Unique Infantry and would be allowed.
• Chaos Demons: All the named demons are Unique Monstrous Creatures, not Independent Characters.  Interestingly, Fateweaver is a Unique Monstrous Creature with only 3 wounds so it would not otherwise be covered by the rules without this wording.
• Tyranid: Most of the named characters are Unique Monstrous Creatures, though Parasite of Mortex is Unique Jump Infantry and Deathleaper is Unique Infantry and would be allowed.

I think that wording strikes a reasonable balance, permitting these manageable, colorful upgrade characters and a few solos, but disallowing the real heavies.

Rules Suggestions

That makes my current thinking on revised Combat Patrol rules something like:

• Missions should set army lists at no more than 250–750 points.
• Armies must include 1 Troop unit and may have up to 2 HQ, 6 Troop, 2 Elite, 2 Fast Attack, and 2 Heavy Support units.
• No Unique Independent Characters, Unique Monstrous Creatures, or Special Characters are permitted.
• No model may have more than 3 wounds.
• Any model with a 2+ Armor Save may not have an Invulnerable save.
• Any model with a 3+ Armor Save may not have better than a 4+ Invulnerable Save.
• In a 500pt or below game, no vehicle may have total armor value (Front+Side+Rear) greater than 33.
• In a 501–750pt game, no vehicle may have total armor value (Front+Side+Rear) greater than 34.
• Units which don’t occupy Force Organization slots, such as Dedicated Transports and Retinues, are permitted caveat the other rules.
• Before deployment, each player must declare one model in their army to be their Patrol Leader. There must not be a model in the army with a higher Leadership value. Note that this implies the Patrol Leader is not a vehicle.
• Missions should be played on 4′x4′ tables.

The Patrol Leader isn’t important for standard mission setups, but I think it’s a handy designation to have in writing custom scenarios given that there’s not necessarily an HQ in each list.  For example, in our tournament preserving or killing Patrol Leaders has been worth Bonus Points on several occasions.

Glancing through the codexes I have and the main rulebook, these rules seem to disallow the following for 750pt games; in general, no named characters are permitted except as discussed above regarding “Uniques”:

• Orks: No Battlewagons.
• Chaos Marines: No Terminators, Oblits, Daemon Princes, Greater Demons, or Land Raider variants.
• Chaos Demons: No Bloodthirsters, or Soul Grinders.
• Daemonhunters: No Grand Masters, Brother Captains, Terminators, or Land Raider variants.
• Tau: Broadsides, Crisis Shas’O Commander, Hammerheads, or Sky Rays.
• Black Templars: No Emperor’s Champions, Terminators, Land Raider variants.
• Space Marines: No Drop Pods, Terminators, or Land Raider variants.
• Necrons: No Wraiths, or Monoliths.
• Imperial Guard: No Leman Russ variants.
• Tyranids: No Swarmlord, Hive Tyrants, Tervigons, Zoanthropes (3+ Inv), Doom of Malantai, Carnifexes, Old One Eye, Trygons, Mawlocs, or Tyrannofexes

Dropping the permitted vehicle armor values to 33 at 500pts further eliminates:

• Orks: No Deff Dreads.
• Chaos Marines: No Predators, Vindicators, Defilers, or Dreadnoughts.
• Space Marines and other Imperials: No Dreadnoughts, Predators, Vindicators, or Dreadnoughts.
• Imperial Guard: No Hellhound variants, Death Strikes, Valkyries or Vendettas,

Those rules also eliminate some wargear and combinations, such as Storm Shields combined with Artificer Armor.  Interestingly, Mycetic Spores have only 3 wounds and a 4+ save, so Tyranids would always have their Drop Pod.  For Synapse they would be able to choose from Tyranid Primes, the Parasite of Mortex, and Zoanthropes.

Conclusion

I had sort of thought the forthcoming 40k Missions Book from GW would have material along these lines, including revised Kill Team or Combat Patrol rules and missions.  The part of me that refuses to accept that they don’t playtest or think about a lot of their design products nearly as much as the community does was actually hoping for that.  However, that doesn’t seem to be the case.

Of the suggested rules above, I feel pretty comfortable with the vehicle restrictions.  The armor and invulnerable save restrictions however might be too permissive however.  I’ll have to think about them more.  As always, comments are welcome!

I track my games played on BoardGameGeek, so I am happy to report that tonight I played my 50th game of 40k, ever.  I started playing in the spring of ‘08, so that seems reasonable when you figure in a majority of them are small games—250pt Lunchhammer, 400pt and 750pt Combat Patrol, etc., with multiple games played in one normal length session.  At this landmark I have to say I’m pretty happy about it.  My few months playing 4th Edition yielded many many frustrations with a poorly written rulebook.  I’m glad to say most of those issues have been resolved in the new core rulebook, so hopefully the ongoing problems with rules writing and so on in the codexes will be resolved in the next edition!  I’ll also say that as I’ve learned to play better I’ve found the game increasingly tactical and strategic, particularly with the increased mobility and other improvements in the 5th Edition rules.

As for tonight, Alex has unfortunately had to unexpectedly drop out of the PAGE/Redcap’s Combat Patrol Tournament due to a commitment with the reserves, so Buford, Lorenzo O, and I got together so I could proxy his match with Buford.  In summary, we’re handling byes/defaults in the following way: The odd player out is guaranteed two Minor Victories.  However, if a proxy match can be set up, they can earn more points.  This seems to strike a reasonable balance between not giving away too many points for the bye while also not penalizing that player either.

Match Setup

Rules were the same as my report last week, and are up on the mission page: The campaign defender is trying to break through and alert primary defenses on the incoming invasion.  The campaign attacker, of course, wants to stop this.

Buford brought out his Space Wolves in a matchup with my Kingbreakers.  This chance to replay this mission was particularly interesting to me as in my last 7 or so 40k games I’ve played all Imperial Guard or Tyranid.  I definitely had to get back into an anti-power armor mindset.  Toward that end, I loaded up on plasma cannons, meltaguns, and heavy bolters:

• 6xSternguard w/ Power Sword, 2xCombi-Melta, Razorback
• 10xTactical w/ Powerfist, Plasmagun, Plasma Cannon, Rhino
• 10xTactical w/ Meltagun, Plasma Cannon, Razorback
• Landspeeder w/ Multi-Melta, Heavy Bolter

Buford brought the Space Wolves equivalents of roughly:

• 5xScouts
• 6xTactical w/ Powerfist, Razorback w/ Lascannon, Plasmaguns
• 6xTactical w/ Powerfist, Razorback w/ Lascannon, Plasmaguns
• 4xBike Squad w/ 1 Attack Bike, Heavy Bolters, Melta Bombs
• Chaplain on Bike

Game 1

For the first game I took the campaign attacker role, defending against the rush.  I rolled to choose and selected to deploy and go first.  Again I was hoping to push forward and stop Buford down on his end of the table, making it harder for any units to make last minute rushes for the table edge.  However, this did force me to spread out across the table to try and block all approaches.  I also had to keep in mind that his Space Wolves Scouts would quite likely enter via my table edge and then immediately run off, so I needed to be prepared to hit them if possible.  Unusually for my recent games, I also broke up both Tactical Squads, with the two Plasma Cannon squads sitting in cover ready to fire away.

Buford basically split his forces between the bikes and the Razorbacks.  The bikes repeatedly turboboosted their way along the one, rushing for the edge, while the Razorbacks advanced more slowly.  I was very happy to see this turboboost attack as in writing the mission scenario that had seemed like a clear, dangerous strategy people would try.

I harried the bikes a bit with Plasma Cannon and Landspeeder fire, but neither accomplished much.  In the end the gambit was stopped by driving Tactical 1’s Razorback across from the middle of the table in its swing position blocking that lane, then assaulting the bikes.  I figured this would result in the death of Tactical 1, which it did, but it held the bikes up for a few turns and killed a few models.  After that they were weakened, held up, and bunched together, ripe to be finished off by the remaining Plasma Cannon and Landspeeder.

Meanwhile, the Plasma Cannons traded shots with one Buford’s Razorbacks, crippling it early in the game.  Definitely the most useful shooting I’ve had with the Plasma Cannons against vehicles.  In a heroic move, however, the Scouts Outflanked directly behind one of the Plasma Combat Squads and obliterated four its Marines in a single impressive round of Bolt Pistol shooting.  The scouts then assaulted the Plasma Cannoneer and then ran off the board, the hit and run attack ensuring I could not get a Major Victory.

On the other side of the board, the two pairs of Razorbacks traded fire with the Kingbreakers’ machines immobilized fairly early.  This left Sgt Titus to carry out one of his typical actions, running directly into the oncoming enemy to successfully destroy the inbound enemy transport.  This resulting in several waves of melee, with his squad eventually wiped out by the Space Wolves, only for they in turn to be caught up in the Sternguard’s counter attack.  Although costly, these assaults ensured there was no time for the Space Wolves to slog through on foot to exit the table.

Game 2

The second game had to be called due to time after the third round, but I was quite comfortable according Buford the victory.  Buford won the deployment roll and opted to go first.  Between that and his strong anti-vehicle components in the Lascannon Razorbacks, he was able to set up a solid pincer scheme with his units.  Most of my army made it pretty far across the table, and some would have escaped, but the vehicles were all stopped just short of where they needed to get to.  The Meltaguns and Combi-Meltas all failed to take out the opposing Razorbacks in time, leaving the Kingbreakers exposed to heavy shooting as well as the predations of the very mobile bike squadron.  My Landspeeder also died early, assaulted and brought down after rushing headlong into the enemy.

Lessons Learned

I was pretty happy with my army in the first game, defending against the rush.  Some mistakes were definitely made for the second game though, attacking.  My heavy reliance on transports was simply shut down by Buford’s Lascannons.  A group of Assault Marines jumping across the table definitely would have been better in many respects.

I also should not have rushed my Landspeeder forward as quickly.  I simply discounted how many attacks he’d be able to bring to bear on it.  Although its Flat Out cover save protected it against all shooting, and nearly every close combat attack failed, one got through, and it only took one.  That was a big loss because it gave me little long reach capability to take out the Lascannons.

More to the point, it was probably a mistake to take only one Landspeeder.  I dropped one because they start getting hard to fit in the list when kitted out with Multi-Meltas and another weapon—70 points for an MM and Heavy Bolter.  Although useful against the bikes, it probably would have been better to drop the Heavy Bolter and a Sternguard or whatnot to put two Landspeeders out there with Multi-Meltas for vehicle hunting.

Even more generally, I probably shouldn’t have advanced so quickly.  I was hoping to quickly book for the table edge and exit, but it probably would have worked better to advance more slowly.  The Lascannons are simply too lethal to Rhinos and Razorbacks when exposed for mulitple turns.  Buford’s bike squad was also a significant problem as its high speed enabled it to quickly move around hitting any critical problem areas.  A single Landspeeder just can’t do much against a good sized bike squadron, particularly after it’s quickly dispatched by them, so I really could have used more units with mobility to counter act them.

All in all though, a couple goods games, and a great time finally meeting Lorenzo O and Buford!

More photos are available in the Flickr set.

Lots of miniatures gaming at PAGE tonight.  First up, Colin and Anthony played out their match for the second round of the 40k Combat Patrol Tournament:

We also had seven people playing Battlefleet Gothic!  This was by far the largest showing for BFG so far at PAGE, and especially noteworthy as none of the Harmons, our regular fleet commanders, were involved.  Steve Smith and Matt Lechtenberg provided the models, but I think they made several converts for future fleet admirals!

I really could have sworn I took more photos of Matt’s fleet and amazing space board, but I guess somehow I whiffed on that.  Probably too focused on getting hammered in my own game.  Damn the torpedos, full speed ahead!  Literally… Some of the first damage in our 3-player game came when a torpedo shot made its way around the sun, my Infidel escort narrowly escaping early game disaster, but my Hades cruiser boosting full speed ahead, directly into the torpedos!  Blindsided by the shot across the sun, the ship was wracked with explosions, but they only served to auger its wrath further!

Although I’d read the rules some time previously, this was my first game of BFG.  Initial impressions were very favorable.  It’s pretty streamlined and seemed to have a good amount of tactics.  I could believe it will also become even more strategic with a larger fleet—we kept things very simple for a first time out, merely a cruiser and an escort each in my game.  My biggest concern game-wise is that it’s fairly fiddly with models.  As facing is important, and straightline trajectories critical for many aspects, precise movement and measuring is important.  Measuring stem to stem is also frequently a bit more difficult to spot than simply base to base.  But, among friends, those are minor qualms, and the speed slowdowns are recouped by the relatively low numbers of models.  Although backlogged on models and going into a typically busy period of the year with little gaming, I’m looking forward to playing this again and perhaps building up a small fleet.

Finally, in closing, boardgaming also happened!  Perhaps most interestingly, Kurt and Jeff continued knocking out round after round of playtesting for their new WWII commandos game.

More photos from the evening are available in the Flickr set.

Robin and I played our match for Round 2 of the PAGE/Redcap’s Combat Patrol tournament.  He elected to continue using the 4th Edition Tyranid book for the moment.  The new book changes a lot of things, making many units unavailable in Combat Patrol, so several of our players are for the moment sticking with the old book until they can figure out some new 5e Tyranid small-games lists.

Match Rules

The second scenario is a simple breakout mission.  The campaign defender is trying to escape the encirclement and alert primary defenses, while the campaign attacker is trying to prevent that.  The writeup is available on the tournament page, but the key point is that the defender is trying to exit half his units off the attacker’s table edge.  The campaign attacker absolutely needs to prevent that; their units are more or less expendable toward that goal…

Armies

I believe Robin brought:

• 28 Gaunts, split into 3 squads, all with Flesh Hooks and Without Number.
• 6 Warriors with a variety of weapons, split into 2 squads
• 2 Lictors

For my Kingbreakers I brought:

• 5xSternguard w/ 2 Combi-Flamers with Razorback
• 10xMarines w/ Powerfist, Flamer, Missile Launcher with Rhino
• 10xMarines w/ Chainsword, Flamer, Missile Launcher, with Razorback
• 2xLandspeeders with 2xHeavy Flamers each

Game 1

Sergeant Scolirus hung slightly out of the exit hatch of his Rhino, holding on by the tips of his Powerfist.  He gazed into the distance, watching the tops of the trees sway and crash to the ground as the horde of massive beasts made their way toward his position.  After a long moment he looked down at Captain Angholan and stretched out his hand.  The captain’s exquisitely crafted armor glittered in the sun as he reached out and clasped his arm to Scolirus’ forearm.  “No matter what, get the warning through,” Angholan said quietly, then paused and in a deeper voice closer to his battle speech added “Till tomorrow or the Emperor.”  Scolirus shook his friend’s arm tighly, then swung back into his vehicle.  The captain pivoted on his heels and leaped into the hatchway of his own Rhino, his dark blue robes fluttering in the breeze.  Scolirus could hear his battle brother already issuing orders at rapid pace.  A flight of Landspeeders thundered by just meters overhead as the captain’s Razorback throttled into high gear and jumped after them, the battle begun before the captain had even secured himself in his transport.  Scolirus’ Rhino roared to life and dove into place in the column behind Angholan and the Landspeeders, ready to follow the linebreakers through to whatever may come beyond…

We placed a fair amount of terrain, a mix of craters, forests, rocks, and a large ruin that really choked up the board.  I rolled to choose and opted to deploy and go second.  Robin spread his forces out to cover both basic approaches, and I tried to stay in the center to not reveal too much about what direction I would take.  Sternguard, Tac 1, and Tac 2 all climbed into their transports.  Tac 2’s Combat Squad with the Missile Launcher deployed just to the left to give some cover fire.  The Landspeeders nestled in behind the transports, hoping for some coer if anything should manage to get a shot off at them in Turn 1.

To recap the game quickly by major thrusts: Landspeeders dispatched left and right to try and tie up both opposing forces.  All of the transports shifted left and drove pretty hard to try and concentrate force on a single point of the enemy line.  The Landspeeders devastated the Gaunt squads, and tore up the Warriors as well.  Sgt Harbinger’s Razorback got hung up on difficult terrain, as did a Landspeeder, but his Sternguard simply piled out and provided cover fire to finish taking down the Warriors on the left side and the Lictors that arrived alongside the exit route.  Scolirus and Titus revved their transports, flying them over the debri and escaping to sound the alarm, driving at full tilt amidst groups of fleeing Gaunts scattering into the forests.

Result: Major victory for me by getting half my units (round down) off the board, and both bonus points (enemy Patrol Leader dead, my Patrol Reader ok).

Game 2

I rolled to choose and opted to go first.  I wanted to go second so I could deploy in response to Robin’s positioning, but chose first so I could move aggressively and try to push the conflict as far forward on the table as I could.  I hoped that even if I couldn’t stop everything, hopefully I could slow it down far enough back on the board that they wouldn’t make it off the table in time.  Tac 1 went to the far left to cover the paths along the edge.  The Stenguard’s Razorback also went left, but they settled down among some rubble on the right to better cover the more open approach.  Titus’ Razorback and Tac 2’s Missile Launcher Combat Squad also settled down on that side.

Robin responded by puting two thirds of his Gaunts in a cluster around his Warriors in the center of the board, obscured by the ruins.  The other Gaunts and Warriors deployed left somewhat, as a combo diversionary and flanking maneuver.

Recapping: My vehicles advanced quickly, hoping to push the line forward.  The Landspeeders, emboldened by their survivability in the first game, moved aggressively into enemy territory.  The Sternguard and Tac 2’s Combat Squad, meanwhile, sniped away at the bigger monsters on the left.

Unfortunately, the Landspeeders did not hold up nearly as well this game.  Both were effectively mission killed early in the game by massed Gaunt fire rolling just enough hits to take out weapons and shake or stun the crew.  This enabled the Tyranid clusters to move up safely without being harrassed and with relatively little regard for bunching up.  The flanking Marines eventually whittled these down, but not quickly enough.  The central Warriors jumped onto the ruins and put some heavy casualties on Tac 2’s Combat Squad.  Literally every Kingbreaker unit on the board fired at them, hoping to take them down while in that exposed position.  It was not to be, however, as one Warrior made it through the hail of fire with one wound intact, and slipped down into the rubble.

Meanwhile, the Lictors popped up deep in my backfield and quickly simply ran off the table to alert the Hivemind and meet the mission objectives.  On the left side, the Warriors there also survived just enough to make it through and tie down Harbinger’s Sternguard in close combat.  Between that, the Landspeeders being out, and spending too much time slaughtering gaunts with the other units, that left no unit in position to stop the central Warrior, which burst from the rubble a turn later and quickly left the board in pursuit of the Lictors.

Result: By getting three units off the board, Robin took a Major Victory.  We both got a bonus point for keeping our Patrol Leaders alive—Robin’s was the sneaky Warrior that slipped through the rubble and snuck through to freedom.

Lessons

These were actually a couple pretty good games.  I was very happy with the first one, less because of the result, and more because I came in with a plan—take second, concentrate force on one point and drive through to break the line—that worked pretty well.  The second game I made a few mistakes and it came down to a couple different die rolls that really could have changed the outcome, so it was a good time.

• Flamer List: This list seemed to do pretty well against the ‘Nids, and I assume will hold up well to the 5e upgrade.  There’s no real way to take Vulkan at these point levels even if special characters were allowed in Combat Patrol, but otherwise he’d be a clear choice.  Faced with a mostly power armor based target environment I don’t use flamers much, but here I pretty obviously had to go with it, and it largely paid off.
• ‘Speeders: These guys did awesome in the first game.  In the second they really took too much firepower and became too crippled too fast to really do a ton.  Normally I’d be all about units soaking up firepower like that, but in this case my other units were expendable—the mission objectives put very little priority on campaign attacker units surviving—and I really needed the super mobile flamers on the Landspeeders to chase down any escaping bugs.  All in all I’ve been pretty happy with my Landspeeders, and tonight was no exception.
• Sternguard: These guys have always been one of my MVPs, and they continued to carry that line tonight.  One interesting point is that I used the special ammo a lot more than I have previously.  In almost all previous games I’ve mostly only had occassion to use Hellfire rounds; maybe occassionally a Kraken or Dragonfire shot, but the Hellfire has been far and away the most useful.  Here I used all three of those alot—to snipe from a distance, to work around the large amounts of cover, and to pummel units caught exposed in the open.  This was really neat, although it almost felt like cheating—of course, of course they’ve got an ammo type that just happens to be perfect for this situation!  No, that’s not written in my book in pencil!  Good stuff though.  I liked them abandoning the Razorback that blew tracks on the rocks, running alongside the remainder of the convoy and sniping away at the Warriors on the roof above them and in the rocks ahead, helping the Landspeeders to clear a path.
• Luck: Sometimes it just doesn’t work out.  In the second game once the Warriors jumped up on top of the ruins, I poured in literally all my firepower.  If something’s worth shooting, it’s worth shooting a lot.  I was really hoping to basically end the game there by taking away the only Synapse creatures in position, crippling the movement of the remaining Gaunts, and stopping the fastest units on the board (they had wings).  It wasn’t to be, however,  That one last guy just shook it off, dancing through the cover.  There was a very thematic moment of him roaring in rage on the rooftop, shots pouring in from all over, and then diving into the ruins for cover, the escape basically complete at that point.
• Position: That said, I should have been able to cover for that.  I waited too long to bring back my forward Rhino and Razorback.  They were hanging out devastating the Gaunts, but really they should have moved back earlier once the aggressive line broke a little, and been in place to cover the Warrior escaping through the central ruins.
• Position II: Similarly, not protecting the rear crater was a huge mistake.  I didn’t put a unit into it originally because it had no line of sight so it would have been basically wasting a unit.  When I deployed I also wasn’t thinking about the Lictors coming down and just running off the board.  I was much more concerned about them coming down immediately on the sides of my lines and taking them on.  Sadly, I had spent some time on the way over to the game thinking about exactly this kind of move.  However, I had been thinking about it only in terms of whether or not I should have written the mission scenario to eliminate it (I decided not).  I never really thought about it in player terms, and that game back to cost me a good number of points.
• Deployment: I probably should have also taken second turn again in the second game.  I didn’t because I really wanted to push the line forward before the bugs got to move, but those extra inches weren’t worth it.  Much better would have been to go second and see where Robin deployed, just like in the first game.  In this case it would have let me see he really wasn’t going to go down the left side, and I could have pulled at least the far flanking Rhino and Tac Squad and put them somewhere more useful, buffing up the right flank or covering the rear crater and center path.
• Vehicle killing: Without their big units, old Tyranids really struggle at combating vehicles under Combat Patrol rules.  Not having really seen it, the new book nonetheless sounds a lot more balanced between assault, shooting, and psychic abilities.  I could believe there are many more options for managing vehicles; hopefully some are available in Combat Patrol.
• Tarpitting: In the second game I was stuck in the usual Tyranid mindset of hanging out in vehicles and avoiding close combat.  That was silly; survival of my units had very little to do with meeting the mission objectives.  Everybody should have move forward then dumped and spread out, doing a better job at physically impeding the bugs’ progress.  Even if a few units got chewed up, it really wouldn’t have mattered as long as they’d been slowed down enough.  Vehicles just can’t bog down units and impede there progress like infantry can, even if the latter are going to die…  I let my fear and standard tactics get the best of me, and didn’t think well enough about the particular mission objectives in play.
• Dozer blades: On the way over I was seriously considering dropping the combi-flamers or something in order to buy dozer blades for the Razorbacks and Rhino.  Given the directions to place more terrain than usual, and the mission requirement to basically hustle across as fast as possible, this seemed like a good chance to actually use them.  In the end I didn’t because I don’t have any modeled on and wasn’t convinced it’d be worth it.  That decision was more or less reasonable, though it could go either way.  I did hang up the Razorbacks on terrain a couple times, but mobility of my tanks seemed mostly ok.  My Landspeeders on the other hand were repeatedly immobilized landing on difficult or impassible terrain.  Robin’s winged warriers also took a lot of wounds from jumping into cover.  If only there were some upgrade to help the speeders with that; it would probably be more worthwhile than dozer blades for tanks…

So, two interesting games.  Early feedback from Jason and Steve was that the campaign defender’s objective of crashing through the line and exiting the board was crazy hard and couldn’t be done.  If nothing else, I think tonight’s action showed the mission is reasonably balanced, all else being equal, and whether or not it’s doable in each match will depend on what all else is not equal—other armies, play styles, etc.  They also left me looking forward to seeing what’s different in the new Tyranid codex; should be a challenge!

Finally got around to posting photos from last weekend’s Combat Patrol Tournament kickoff at Redcap’s Corner.  Twelve players showed up, out of sixteen in the tournament, not bad showing.  Redcap’s recently completed switch to takeover the adjacent video store’s space seems to have turned out very well—the bottom space is very large and bright, with tons of room and tables for gaming, plus a good bit of potential shelf space.  Somewhat more unconventionally, they’ve built a little loft above it for roleplaying and miniatures gaming.  It needs some finishing and more lighting, but should be really cool when done—a quieter place to play, away from the card gamers.  It also has really nice custom gaming tables that the store did a great job knocking out.

More photos on Flickr: Here.

As announced earlier, I am currently running a multi-week 40k Combat Patrol tournament here in Philadelphia.  We just finished Round 1, and things are going fairly well.  Sixteen people have joined the party, and there’s a decent mix of armies.  The only really surprising omission is the lack of Imperial Guard, but it sounds like several of the guys with new IG armies haven’t graduated them to their tournament faction yet.  Last week we had a really good group session with twelve people playing at Redcap’s Corner in West Philadelphia.  This coincided with their grand reopening after expanding the store, and it was a great time.  The new space is awesome and many good games were played.

One of the plans I have for the tournament is to take the campaign oriented mission writeups, package them up with my notes on running the tournament, and post them up afterward for other groups to use in running similar events with minimal work.  Toward that end, I’m going to record some of my design notes and observations here as we go along.

Combat Patrol

Perhaps most fundamentally, there are some mixed reactions to the Combat Patrol rules.  Our restrictions follow fairly faithfully from those in the 4th Edition rulebook but at 750 points, and feelings are positive but a few issues have come up.

On the positive side, this setup has four big advantages going for it:

• The tournament is more accessible.  Running at a low points scale and with mostly only core units allowed, more players will be able to jump in.  As a bonus, it also means more players will have fully painted armies, a nice side effect.  I will note though that this has had only mixed success; we did not pull in quite the crowd of new people I was hoping to.
• Games only require 4×4 tables, which means you can fit a good number of matches into a small space.  We have a lot of room at Redcap’s and PAGE, but 4×6 tables are a limited supply at the latter and the former is contested by card players (mostly Magic).  Physically fitting more games just makes things easier at a lot of venues.
• Small games like these can be played in 90–120 minutes.  I’ve taken advantage of that to set up asymmetric missions where a match consists of two games with players alternating rounds.  At 750 points that can easily be done in three hours, and therefore still works well for people to get together and play after work.
• Perhaps most importantly though, and most conflicted, the restrictions generally keep crazy and specialized units out of the game.  This also helps accessibility, leveling the playing field a great deal: You know you won’t go up against someone who’s invested in a handful of Landraiders or has every model on hand to pick and choose from for an optimal list.  I don’t have a problem with that at all, but it can be discouraging to new people.
  What also happens is that the restrictions take some of the tactics out of list construction and puts them back onto the table.  Since everyone’s forced to focus on core, common units, it’s a lot more predictable what people will have, and the forces are a lot more similar.  I certainly don’t have a problem at all with good list construction, and really enjoy that as a key aspect of the game.  However, at these low point levels it’s very susceptible to rock, paper, scissors effects, where a game’s outcome is dominated by good, bad, or unexpected list selections.  Given that small games have advantages otherwise, reducing that effect is a good thing.

However, the restrictions also raise some problems.  Some people are turned off by the lack of crazy units, and don’t see big gains in board tactics focus or value in reducing the rock, paper, scissors effect.  That’s basically a style choice; I think the former is just different, not better, but the latter is important for games of this size.

Worse though is that the Combat Patrol rules aren’t holding up well under the 5th Edition codexes.  Just like we bumped the points to 750 to better suit codexes with expensive units, such as Necrons, with the additional restrictions there are just so many units barred from play that it’s a little overkill.  I was really, really sad to realize my Drop Pods would not be legal, and neither would my Captain.  I don’t see either of those as unstoppable at this point level, but the loss of the Drop Pods especially has really changed my play style, and forced me to scrounge together some Rhinos—in complete contrast to the goal of enabling people to play with anything they have on hand.  Similarly, I don’t see huge problems in allowing in an IG Company Commander.  Tyranid players also seem really cramped by the rules, with very few permitted unit choices in the new book.  The newer books seem to trend toward having more wounds, armor, and so on floating around, frequently making previously available units forbidden in Combat Patrol.

I can see some value in keeping out Landraiders, Terminators, special characters, Chaos Sorcerors, etc. at this point level and game style.  But, I think in the future I would relax the restrictions, probably allowing 3 wounds, 36 armor, and possibly 2+ saves.  I would definitely even consider letting anything go; at 750 points these kinds of balance issues are less of a problem than at the standard Combat Patrol 400 points, and a lot of it is self balancing.  Yes, a Landraider could be hugely dominating.  But a couple Sternguard could also drop it in Turn 1 and wipe out a third of your points…  I certainly foresee spending a good bit of time revisiting this issue for future events.

New Codexes

I expected the new Tyranid codex to drop in the middle of the tournament and wanted to afford players some flexibility.  People might not be able to get it quickly, it might invalidate their models, and so on.  I therefore put this in the tournament rules:

Current codexes must be used. However, players of armies with codexes released during the tournament may opt to use either the latest or previous codex, declared before a match begins.

However, what I really should have said was:

Current codexes must be used.  However, players of armies with codexes released during or up to two weeks before the tournament begins may opt to use either the latest or previous codex.  They must inform their opponents which book they are using when arranging a match, and once they upgrade to the newer book they must not switch back to the older book for their remaining matches..

This won’t actually be an issue for us because we have a good group with the right attitude, but it addresses a couple potential issues:

• More leeway is needed for when the book comes out; it being released the day before the tournament starts versus the day after doesn’t really change the core issues such as book availability and reworking models or lists, but in the original wording everyone would technically be forced to upgrade.
• The original intent was definitely that opponents could plan around which book would be used but the original wording didn’t actually quite say that, so it is spelled out better in the second version.  Not that I think it’s a huge issue at this point level and with these restrictions, but it’s definitely the more sporting approach so it may as well be formalized.
• Similarly, allowing people to switch back and forth between books in some attempt to tune to the mission or opponent seems very gamey and unsporting.  The second wording encodes that intent and eliminates that problem.

Starting & Registration

The tournament is being run in a multi-week format with only a fixed date for the climactic, dramatic final round(s).  In the interim, players schedule their matches as they please to fit their schedule.  This is working out well so far in enabling people flexibility to participate, but it has made the start a little awkward.  For example, I still don’t have contact information for some people who were registered by their friends.  It’s working—they’re making their matches and so on—but it’s a little cumbersome.  In the future I would definitely consider having a mandatory session for the first round as well so that I can physically collect all the contact information, registration fees, etc., and then roll from there rather than trying to play catchup with people for a couple days or weeks.

In any event, so far so good, and I’m looking forward to a bunch of fun, tough matches in the next couple weeks.  More details on games and notes on the tournament and campaign to come!

To properly kick off the new year of gaming at PAGE, I got in a round of 40k tonight with Kiril, a guest visiting from Bulgaria.  He said there are so few players where he lives, he had to bring an army to the US and look for some games while here for winter break!  Hopefully he’ll return at some point, a great guy and a good player.

Rules

We tried out the first scenario for the upcoming Combat Patrol tournament.  Army rules are on the tournament webpage, but are the usual Combat Patrol constraints except at 750pts rather than 400.  In this scenario, a lonely listening post has been struck by the leading edge of an incoming assault!  The Defender player must hold the outpost long enough to make contact with command and relay the warning.  The Attacker must overrun the base and prevent that from happening.

• Goal: A single objective is placed along the central axis, 12″ from the Defender table edge on a 4′x4′ board.
• Deployment: Defender deploys 16″ from their table edge; Attacker deploys 8″ from the opposite edge.
• Play order: Defender deploys first; Attacker chooses to go first or second.
• Other notes: Standard mission rules (end game, Reserves, etc).

The match consists of two games with players alternating as the Attacker and Defender.

Armies

Kiril brought an infantry oriented Imperial Guard contingent, roughly consisting of:

• 40 regular Guardsmen; in the first game they were in 4 squads but in the second he grouped them into 2
• Veterans with 2 meltaguns and a heavy flamer riding in a Chimera
• Autocannon and mortar teams
• Platoon command squad with 2 flamers
• Company command squad (violates Combat Patrol 3 wound rule, but not a huge worry for these games)

The Kingbreakers in turn brought out:

• 10xTactical Squad w/ Powerfist, Plasmagun, Missile Launcher, Rhino (240pts)
• 10xTactical Squad w/ Meltagun, Plasma Cannon, Razorback (220pts)
• 5xSternguard w/ Power Sword, 2xCombi-Melta, Razorback (190pts)
• Thunderfire Cannon (100pts)

Battle 1

Kingbreakers begin the assault on a heretical hive city, accused of conspiring with the Xenos Tau to gain advanced weaponry, by storming the outlying listening posts!

The Kingbreakers’ Thunderfire Cannon and Combat Squad Jericho with his plasma cannon bunker down behind debris on the outskirts of the base, hoping to rain plasma and shells down on hapless Guardsmen in the hills around the bunker.  Razorbacks with Tactical Squad Titus and Captain Angholan [proxying a Sternguard Sergeant] with Sternguard Squad Harbinger move to advance up the west and into the bordering foothills.  However, the transports are shredded to disassembled components by heavy incoming Guard missiles and the squads find what cover they can behind the burning ruins.

Meanwhile, Tactical Squad Scolirus leverages the heavy fire poured onto Titus and Angholan to race deep into enemy territory.  Their transport is destroyed as wall, but not before delivering their vengeance directly into the enemy mortars pummeling their now-exposed battle brothers Titus and Angholan.

Regrouped from the explosive loss of their vehicle, Angholan leads the  Sternguard clambering over the rocky foothills into cover but are surprised by a group of Imperial Guard veterans dashing into the battle in their Chimera.  The firefight is brief but lethal; Angholan and his men are eventually brought down by sheer numbers and profligate quantities of fusion blaster [melta] fire.  Harbinger’s only solace as he barely escapes after being critically injured is having flushed the conspiracy into the open, reporting the fusion weapons as sure evidence of traitorous pacts with the diminutive xenos!

Meanwhile, Sergeant Titus leads his squad in a running gun battle with the Chimera and many supporting heavy weapons units.  Though tougher to break than expected, the Chimera is eventually destroyed in a dangerous close action krak grenade attack.  Its burning hulk provides meager shelter by which Titus, the sole survivor, attempts a daring lone assault on the objective command post.  Alas, it is too much, too far, even for that mighty warrior of the Imperium, and he is unable to brush off its defending crew and prevent successful transmission warning of the Kingbreakers’ imminent main assault…

Game 2

For reasons unannounced and unclear, an Imperial Guard unit assults a small Kingbreakers outpost!

The bulk of the Kingbreakers on hand rapidly assemble a basic gunline defending the outpost perimeter.  Squad Scolirus leads the charge to take the fight to the enemy, rushing to outflank the enemy and directly attack its supporting units in the rearguard, his transport zig-zagging and popping smoke furiously to avert heavy incoming fire.

Unperturbed by the swift reaction of the Kingbreakers, the Guardsmen move quickly, rushing forward through the foothills to the west of the outpost in an attempt to avoid incoming Thunderfire and plasma cannon fire.  Mechanized Veterans rapidly deploy, moving with all haste to engage Jericho’s plasma cannon contingent lurking outside the outpost.  The Veterans are quickly withered though by Squad Jericho, the plasma cannoneer blasting away at full tilt to dangerously close minimum distances in a successful last ditch effort to break the experienced shocktroopers’ thrust.

Shielded behind the Chimera and heroic lead of the Veteran squad, dozens of troopers run in their tracks.  Officers bray commands and drive their men on at full speed but, alas, the foothills hinder their mobility too much, leaving them moving forward at agonizing speed, too slow to breach the outer outpost defenses.

Meanwhile, mortar and autocannon crews in the rear fight furiously to pin down Harbinger’s Sternguard overwatching the outpost, and clear a safe path for their comrades bravely, foolishly rushing up through the Kingbreakers’ primary field of fire to assault the bunker.  Their work is undone however as the mortar crews are cut to ribbons by bolter and chainsword as the flanking Scolirus reaches their position, and the autocannon teams are forced to evacuate their position by the precise, unperturbed sniping of the Stearnguard.  Unsupported by any suppressive fire, the main assaulting group is left exposed in the center field and is decimated by Thunderfire Cannon shelling.  As Squad Titus sweeps in to pick off the survivors of the shelling, the outpost is all but secured from the sudden, maniacal foot assault.

Results

Battle 1: Kiril’s IG successful held off the Kingbreakers’ attack.  The Marines suffered many casualties, and were not in place to contest the bunker at the endgame.

Battle 2: The Kingbreakers kept the IG at distance, gutting their lead forces and leaving no one in position to charge the outpost in time.

Notes

This was a great battle.  I had not previously played against someone very comfortable with the new IG codex, and it was a lot of fun.  The army feels very different to fight than many others.  It has a soft underbelly, at least as soft as the Tau, with men going down rapidly. However, it has a distinct horde quality and puts up a fiercesome amount of firepower, even without many vehicles.  A lasgun may not seem like much, but when a dozen or two of them are shooting two or three shots each at a group of Marines, odds say someone’s going to take some wounds.  It was also really neat watching the orders fly around and really change the action of the force.  Kiril made heavy use of Run, Run, Run!, Take It Down!, and especially First Rank, Fire! Second Rank, Fire!, all of which worked to great effect.

I don’t think I played the first game very well, splitting up my forces too much and not having clear goals.  Instead of trying to sweep the sides and take out the supporting units, I should have just rushed right onto the bunker and parked a couple squads on it.  That way I’d at least be contesting it, and putting him back on his heels instead of waiting for me.

The Combat Patrol rules also really hurt my style of play.  Without my Drop Pods I was at a total loss, and relatively unfamiliar with the Rhinos and Razorbacks as more than portable bunkers and fire points. At several key points I forget to pop smoke and other similar things. How to use these is something I’ll have to think about before the Combat Patrol tournament really starts up.  That said, one neat thing in the second game was having Titus rush out in a Razorback to clobber some units, then popping back in to drive over and quickly block another incoming squad.  You can’t do that in a Drop Pod!  At least, you know, without an AdMech lifter or something… …

Similarly, I’ll have to think about how to use the Sternguard in this context, if at all.  I think without the Alpha Assault aspect of them in Drop Pods, they loss a lot of oomph.  That said, their variety of shots was still useful in parking them down as a mini-gunline around the objective.  That fit very much in with the fluff in the codex and worked reasonably well, though it’s not how I usually use them.

The Thunderfire Cannon again had mixed results, though it certainly killed a lot more models than in previous games.  I think I would gladly trade two, maybe even three of its four shots for it to use a large template rather than the small.  Making it a barrage weapon and/or giving it indirect fire would also be a huge boon and make it slightly less tepid.  The range is a big plus, even on the shorter table, and it It did kill a fair bit of things, but I’m still iffy on it.  Not enough to drop it completely, but more than enough to make me really question it against the power armor I am sure to face in the tournament.

One other interesting aspect of the game were the IG’s mortar teams, of which Kiril had 3.  These didn’t really kill a ton of guys, but they kept a lot of units pinned down.  Although useful, the Sternguard were severely crippled for much of the second game by being pinned by mortar hits.  I’ve never rolled so many failed Leadership checks in my life—and it really hurt—but I’ve never had to roll so many before either.  Probably because of my frustration it was actually really neat to watch; it’s exactly the sort of role you can really envision real mortars playing (or, at least, real movie mortars…).

All in all, two great games.  Between the orders, mortars, and general fragility but massed firepower, the IG really seemed a lot more like a real army as portrayed in a movie than the Marines and most other armies do. Definitely really fun to play against, and I’m only more tempted now to start up my own group of Cadians…

More photos of this battle are in my Flickr set!